No one would blame supporters of immigration reform if they were
pessimistic about the chances of getting a comprehensive bill passed
this year. After all, in recent years they’ve already seen one bill go
down in flames, another never get off the ground, and just last year
endured a presidential election in which Republican candidates were
attacked for showing even the slightest sympathy towards undocumented
And yet, activists and politicians working on a bill are sounding
increasingly confident — even cocky — about their chances. There’s a
bipartisan Senate plan already making the rounds, a House group readying
a bill of their own, and a broad coalition of powerful interests from
churches to big business to Republican fundraisers marketing the whole
But most importantly, the months since the election have seen a
number unexpected developments that indicate a bill may have more
momentum than its backers initially hoped.
Everything comes with the caveat that it’s still early and there’s
plenty that could go wrong in the months before a final draft of
legislation, let alone a final vote. But the points in its favor are
piling up too fast to ignore.
Here are five reasons that the prospects for immigration reform are looking a lot better than they were even a few weeks ago:
The House Is Actually Passing Stuff
It used to be assumed that Republican leaders would not schedule a
vote on any bill that didn’t have the support of its own caucus, a group
not exactly known for its warm relationship with undocumented
immigrants. Barely two months into 2013, that assumption is already
kaput. Since the election, Speaker John Boehner (R-OH) has passed a tax deal, Sandy relief, and this week the Violence Against Women Act,
all with large chunks of his own party voting nay. In doing so, he’s
established a new de facto rule: when bills become a political albatross
around the national GOP, he’ll pass them any way he can.
No issue falls under that category more than immigration reform,
which Boehner, Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-VA), and Budget Committee
Chairman Paul Ryan (R-WI), among other Republican leaders, have all
expressed strong interest in passing in some form and soon. Should House
conservatives stall reform while the Senate passes a bill with a strong
bipartisan vote, there will be enormous pressure on Boehner to follow
the route he took on the Violence Against Women Act and bring it to the
“Boehner is ruling the House in a way we didn’t think was possible
just three months ago,” Angela Kelley, vice president for immigration
policy and advocacy at the liberal Center for American Progress, told
TPM. “It’s a good precedent.”
Politicians Are Fighting Away From The Ledge
Republicans raised hell after a draft of the White House’s own
immigration bill leaked last month. And no one was madder than Sen.
Marco Rubio (R-FL), who called it a “half baked” bill that was “dead on
arrival” in the House.
Bad news for immigration reform, right? Well, here’s the funny part.
Rubio’s own Senate plan isn’t all that different in concept than the
White House’s. And the source of the fiercest attacks on reform in
general is border security, an area that Obama’s leaked plan would
bolster. too. In fact, Sens. John McCain (R-AZ) and Lindsey Graham
(R-SC) — not exactly Obama’s best friends lately — emerged from a White House meeting singing the president’s praises on exactly that issue.
Few pro-reform activists seem to think that the Senate plan’s biggest
difference with Obama’s bill, a “trigger” that woud only let
undocumented immigrants apply for a green card and subsequently
citizenship after border security measures took effect, is enough to
threaten a bill. Instead, the argle-bargle over the White House draft
had more to do with the politics of passing a bill, where it’s important
for conservatives like Rubio to keep their distance from Obama, than any actual policy differences. Which brings us to the next green shoot for reform….
Immigration Opponents Are Keeping Quiet
So that thing Rubio is doing, where he rips the White House’s
immigration plan then tells conservatives they should stick it to Obama
by passing his own (mostly similar) version? It might actually be
Rubio’s been making the rounds with the same radio hosts, TV
commentators, and columnists who helped kill immigration reform in 2007,
using his popularity with the tea party right to make the case that his
bipartisan Senate plan is neither “amnesty” nor a sop to Democrats. At
the very least, he’s gotten a pretty respectful welcome, even from hosts
like Rush Limbaugh who are still overtly anti-reform. And in some cases, he’s gotten something approaching begrudging support.
Meanwhile, Fox News is largely getting on the immigration reform train, with Rupert Murdoch, Sean Hannity, and Bill O’Reilly
all saying nice things about legalizing undocumented immigrants. And so
far there isn’t anyone close to the equivalent of Lou Dobbs during the
last immigration debate, a widely watched commentator who makes killing a
bill their raison d’etre.
“The screamers and haters are not dominating the debate they way they
did last time,” Frank Sharry, executive director of the pro-reform
America’s Voice Education Fund, told TPM. “Rubio has had a lot to do
with that: he’s engaged the conservative press in a thoughtful way and
it’s been beneficial.”
Labor And Business Aren’t Killing Each Other
Farm, hotel, and meatpacking companies are looking to immigration
reform to give them a legal route to hire cheap foreign labor, something
that reformers say needs to happen in order to prevent another buildup
of undocumented immigrants. But unions are worried that they’ll end up
using a guest worker program to undercut American workers with easily
Senators working on a bill have bitter memories
of watching their 2007 reform efforts go down in flames as labor groups
opposed its guest worker program and business groups complained that it
didn’t go far enough. This time they’ve asked the two sides to
negotiate their own solution as a possible model, which is no easy task.
So far, however, they’ve actually made some progress:
last month the AFL-CIO and Chamber of Commerce put out a statement of
principles indicating a possible compromise built around a temporary
visa for workers and an independent federal agency to track labor
shortages so workers can tell whether industry’s claims of labor
shortages are legit. Both sides warn that the details are far from
complete, but as long as they keep talking, immigration reform’s chances
for passage are vastly improved.
There’s A Path To A Path To Citizenship
Along with the guest worker fight, the next most contentious issue is
a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants. Democrats and
immigration activists say they’ll walk without a clear route to
citizenship at some point, even if it’s not an immediate one (Obama’s
plan would take at least 13 years to kick in). It’s less clear
how the Senate’s plan works, but it does commit to a path to
citizenship as well, including an expedited route for young undocumented
immigrants and agricultural workers.
The House side is still a mystery, though. There’s a bipartisan group working on a bill that contains an odd mix
of pro-reform progressives and border hawk conservatives and they’ve
yet to leak any significant details about their plan. There’s a lot more
skepticism about a path to citizenship on the House side, but key
Republicans are leaving at least some wiggle room for them to adopt one.
This is made somewhat easier by the fact “path to citizenship,” like
“amnesty” is a vague, malleable term.
Some Republicans, for example, say they’re against a “special path to
citizenship,” but that they’d let undocumented immigrants “get in the
back of the line” behind legal applicants for green cards and
citizenship under a process that actually might give them a chance of being approved.
As for House leadership, top Republicans including Boehner, Cantor, and especially Ryan are going out of their way to encourage bipartisan talks, even if they haven’t pledged to support the results.
Add it all up and immigration reform, while nowhere near passage, is
gliding along about as smoothly as supporters could hope so far.
For More Information Contact us at:
- Eli Kantor
- Beverly Hills, California, United States
- Eli Kantor is a labor, employment and immigration law attorney. He has been practicing labor, employment and immigration law for more than 36 years. He has been featured in articles about labor, employment and immigration law in the L.A. Times, Business Week.com and Daily Variety. He is a regular columnist for the Daily Journal. Telephone (310)274-8216; firstname.lastname@example.org. For more information, visit beverlyhillsimmigrationlaw.com and and beverlyhillsemploymentlaw.com